Aha Stories Get the App

Resilience · 3 min read

Draft Nine

The rejection email arrived on a Tuesday in Dublin, in the dead hour before lunch, and Siobhan read it standing at the kettle.

"Thank you for the opportunity to read your manuscript. Unfortunately, it is not right for our list." The eighth of its kind, near enough identical to the previous seven that she half suspected a template and a sad little machine somewhere stamping them out.

She was thirty-eight, a primary school secretary, and she had written a novel in the hour before work for three years. Her husband said it was brilliant. Her husband was a poor judge, being in love.

She closed the laptop. She did the washing up, which needed no doing. She stood for a time with her hands in the hot water and let the old cruel arguments come. You are not a writer. You are a woman who owns a notebook.

That night she opened the manuscript and, instead of reading it, scrolled to the end. Two hundred and ninety-one pages. She had never actually looked at how large they were. She noticed that somewhere in the middle there was a chapter she genuinely liked, about a lighthouse keeper's daughter and a lost glove, and a chapter near the start that she skimmed because she was embarrassed by it.

Eight editors had said no. None had said why. That was the real injury, the silence around it. So she did the only thing available to her and read it as a stranger would.

She read for two hours. The beginning was slow. The lighthouse chapter should have been the beginning.

She did not feel inspired. She felt tired, and a bit sick, and entirely clear. It was the clarity of seeing a leak in a roof you've been calling a ceiling.

At midnight, she saved a new file. Draft nine. She dragged the lighthouse chapter to the top.

The next morning she sent nothing. She wrote for an hour, as she always did, and went in to school and handed a crying seven-year-old a plaster and a tissue.

It was not a triumph. Rejection did not stop hurting; it stopped being a verdict and became, strangely, notes, a stack of silent, unpaid readers who had made her look again.

On Friday she printed the first page and left it on the table, with a pen, for her husband to mark. "Be cruel," she said.

"I will not."

"Then be accurate," she said, and went to put on the kettle.

“It was the clarity of seeing a leak in a roof you've been calling a ceiling.”

Reflect

What recent no could be treated as a set of notes rather than a verdict?

Tiny challenge for today

Take one recent setback and write down one specific thing you would try differently next time.

Someone sent you this story

Get one like it every morning.

One 3-minute story a day, with a question to think about and a tiny challenge. Free, works offline, no ads while you read. 100K+ people already have it.

What is Aha Stories? →

Aha Stories4.5★ · Free on PlayInstall